Stripe Atlas vs doola vs Firstbase for non-US founders (2026)
By the OutsideFounder editorial team (Heroes Lab LLC) · Editorial policy · Last updated · 9 min read
We earn a commission if you sign up through some links on this page. It never changes scores or order.
General information, not legal, tax, or immigration advice. Disclaimer · How we make money
People often search these three names together. This page compares them on the same published ranking method and 3-year cost table as the rest of the site, and says who each one actually fits.
Short answer
As of : These three are not interchangeable. Stripe Atlas forms only in Delaware (C-Corp or LLC) for a $500 one-time fee that includes Delaware filing fees, the first year of registered agent service and EIN filing, then $100 a year for the agent. doola Starter is $297 a year plus state fees and includes formation, EIN, registered agent and a US business address. Firstbase Start lists $399 one-time for Delaware or Wyoming formation and an expedited EIN; a registered agent is a required add-on at $299 a year. In our 3-year cost table that is $1,500 for Atlas in Delaware, $1,114 for doola Starter in Wyoming, and $1,519 for Firstbase Start plus Agent in Wyoming at the list price. A $99 promotional Start price was still shown on Firstbase's pricing page on November 14, 2026, with no published end date; we budget the $399 list price. None of the entry packages includes Form 5472. Formation services: doola 74.6, Firstbase 72.4, Northwest Registered Agent 69.6. Not ranked (not enough review data): Stripe Atlas. Ranked by our published method (reviews 60%, price transparency 30%, refund terms 10%); commissions are not an input. This is general information, not legal or tax advice.
Key facts
Verified against official sources on .
| Item | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Stripe Atlas setup | $500 one-time, including Delaware filing fees, first year of registered agent service, and EIN filing; registered agent $100/yr after year 1 | Stripe Atlas |
| doola Starter | $297/yr plus state fees; includes formation, EIN, registered agent and a virtual mailing / business address | doola – Pricing and Starter plan help |
| Firstbase Start list price | $399 one-time for Delaware or Wyoming formation and expedited EIN setup. A $99 promotional price was shown on November 14, 2026, with no published end date; our cost table uses the $399 list price | Firstbase – Pricing |
| Firstbase Agent | $299/yr per state; required for incorporation | Firstbase – Pricing |
| Delaware LLC annual tax | $400, due on or before June 1; no annual report required | Delaware Division of Corporations – LLC/LP/GP tax instructions |
| Atlas EIN timing without an SSN | 5–35 business days after incorporation (1–3 business days with an SSN, US address and US phone), per Atlas docs checked November 14, 2026 | Stripe Docs – How to incorporate your company |
| doola EIN timing without an SSN | Typically 4–6 weeks after the SS-4 is faxed; may take up to 8 weeks in peak periods. Expedited is typically around 2 weeks faster. With an SSN, typically 1–3 business days. Estimates, not guarantees. | doola – Formation and EIN timing |
| Form 5472 in the entry packages | Not included. doola: $1,500/yr standalone or $1,999/yr Tax & Compliance. Firstbase: $899/yr for a non-US-owned single-member LLC. Atlas: no price published. | doola add-on pricing; Firstbase pricing; Atlas business taxes |
How this comparison works
We already rank formation services with one fixed method — Bayesian-adjusted Trustpilot reviews (60%), price transparency (30%) and refund terms (10%) — and we price a standard 3-year package on our cost page. This article does not invent a new score. Formation services: doola(Paid link) 74.6, Firstbase 72.4, Northwest Registered Agent 69.6. Not ranked (not enough review data): Stripe Atlas. The full method is on How we rank. Commissions are not an input.
Among these three, doola currently ranks first and Firstbase second. Stripe Atlas is not ranked because we do not have a Trustpilot score for it. Northwest Registered Agent is in the same ranking (third) and is often cheaper over three years than any of these three; it is not in the table below because this page answers the three-way search, but it is in the full formation ranking.
We last checked each provider's official pricing and help pages on November 14, 2026. Prices change. If a number cannot be verified, we say so and tell you to check the provider's page.
Side by side
We earn a commission if you sign up through some links in this section. It never changes scores or order.
The first table uses the same rank, score, 3-year cost, refund terms and Form 5472 notes as our other formation pages, for these three services only, in ranking order (unranked last). The second table adds entity type, state, inclusions and timelines from each provider's official pages, checked November 14, 2026.
| # | Provider | Score (0–100) | 3-year cost (package and state in our cost table) | Refund terms | Form 5472 + pro forma 1120 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | doola | 74.6 | $1,114doola (Starter), Wyoming | Possible only before filing is sent to the state, at doola's discretion | Not in Starter ($297/yr). Included in Tax & Compliance ($1,999/yr). Standalone Annual IRS Tax Filing: $1,500/yr (covers Form 5472 and pro forma 1120 when they apply). |
| 2 | Firstbase | 72.4 | $1,519Firstbase (Start + Agent), Wyoming | Within 7 days and only before set steps; refunds end once you confirm company details after purchase, when work begins; state fees non-refundable | Not in Start. Tax Filing for non-US-owned single-member LLCs (Form 5472 + pro forma 1120): $899/yr. |
| – | Stripe Atlas | Not enough data to rank | $1,500Stripe Atlas (LLC), Delaware | Fee refunded only if Stripe can't support your business, not on request; agent renews automatically, cancel anytime | Not included. Atlas says it doesn't provide tax advice and points to partner tax and accounting services. No price published by Atlas. |
Order and scores follow our published method (ties alphabetical). Partner status is not an input. Last checked: prices and refund terms Oct 17, 2026; Form 5472 options Oct 18, 2026; review data Nov 1, 2026. Cost basis and every line item: 3-year cost comparison.
What each package actually includes
| Item | Stripe Atlas | doola Starter | Firstbase Start (+ Agent where required) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headline price | $500 one-time, including Delaware filing fees | $297/yr plus state fees | $399 list, one-time, plus state fees. $99 promotional price was shown on November 14, 2026, with no published end date |
| 3-year total in our cost table | $1,500 (Delaware LLC, including $400/yr state tax in years 2 and 3 and $100/yr agent after year 1) | $1,114 (Wyoming, including state filing and annual reports) | $1,519 (Wyoming, at the $399 list price, including the required $299/yr Agent and state annual reports) |
| Entity types | Delaware C-Corp or LLC (including a C-Corp subsidiary of an existing company) | US LLC or C-Corp | LLC or C-Corp |
| States | Delaware only | Wyoming and Delaware are the states doola highlights. Its Wyoming page says it can incorporate in any of the 50 US states — confirm the live list at checkout | Delaware or Wyoming for Start. Agent is offered in all 50 states (for example after a foreign qualification) |
| EIN without an SSN | Included (Atlas files Form SS-4) | Included | Included (expedited EIN setup; no SSN or ITIN required, per Firstbase) |
| EIN timing if you have no SSN | 5–35 business days after incorporation, per Atlas docs (1–3 business days with an SSN, US address and US phone). The marketing page says “several weeks” without those three items | Typically 4–6 weeks after the SS-4 is faxed; up to 8 weeks in peak periods. Expedited is typically around 2 weeks faster (doola also lists a $300 Expedited EIN add-on). With an SSN, typically 1–3 business days. Estimates, not guarantees | Firstbase says you can receive the tax ID “in a few days” and describes the EIN as expedited. It does not publish a business-day range for applications without an SSN on the pages we checked — check the provider's page |
| Registered agent | Year 1 included; $100/yr after that, renews automatically. Cancel by giving 30 days' notice to atlas@stripe.com. The agent address is not a general mail-forwarding address | Included in the $297/yr Starter plan | Required add-on: $299/yr per state on the pricing page. (A Firstbase help article still mentioned an older “starts at $149 per year” figure; we use the $299 price on the pricing page) |
| US mailing / business address | Not included. Atlas says you can use a home or virtual address from a partner for the EIN application | Virtual mailing / business address included in Starter | Mailroom add-on, from $35/mo or $315/yr (a premium tier at $50/mo or $350/yr was also shown) |
| Bank or payments help | After incorporation you can apply for Stripe payments and open a Stripe Treasury account, including before the EIN arrives. Approval is not guaranteed, and Treasury is not opened automatically | Guidance to apply for a US business bank account via Mercury. A bank account is not guaranteed | Help opening an account with banking partners. Firstbase says you may apply before the EIN is issued, subject to partner approval (it names Mercury). Not guaranteed |
| Form 5472 + pro forma 1120 | Not included. Atlas says it doesn't provide tax advice and points to partner tax and accounting services. No price published by Atlas. | Not in Starter ($297/yr). Included in Tax & Compliance ($1,999/yr). Standalone Annual IRS Tax Filing: $1,500/yr (covers Form 5472 and pro forma 1120 when they apply). | Not in Start. Tax Filing for non-US-owned single-member LLCs (Form 5472 + pro forma 1120): $899/yr. |
| Yearly state report or tax filing by the provider | Not included. Delaware LLCs pay a $400 official annual tax (due June 1) themselves, or through a tax partner. Atlas's tax page still mentioned a $300 LLC tax when we checked it on November 14, 2026; Delaware's official page lists $400, which is the figure in our cost table | Not in Starter. doola lists State Annual Filing as a $199/yr plus state fee add-on, and includes annual compliance filings on Tax & Compliance and Business-in-a-Box | State annual report and franchise tax filings are listed with the Agent add-on. State fees or taxes owed are paid separately |
| FinCEN BOI report | Not needed for a US-created company under FinCEN's August 2026 final rule. See our BOI guide | Same rule: a US-created LLC does not file a FinCEN BOI report | Same rule. Agent still listed “beneficial ownership information filings” on the pricing page on November 14, 2026; we could not verify what that filing is, or whether it costs extra. Do not pay for a FinCEN BOI report for a US-created LLC |
| Formation timeline | Most companies incorporated within one business day; docs say Delaware filing usually takes 1–2 business days | Pricing FAQ says Starter formation is filed in 1–2 business days. State approval then depends on the state and the season; doola does not guarantee a fixed approval date | Firstbase says paperwork can come back in as little as a week, depending on how quickly the state processes the filing |
| Refund terms (summary) | Fee refunded only if Stripe can't support your business, not on request; agent renews automatically, cancel anytime | Possible only before filing is sent to the state, at doola's discretion | Within 7 days and only before set steps; refunds end once you confirm company details after purchase, when work begins; state fees non-refundable |
| Non-resident support | Founders from anywhere; no US citizenship, residency, address or SSN required to incorporate. A US address and phone can speed up the EIN. Atlas terms separately list prohibited jurisdictions (Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Syria, and the Crimean region of Ukraine) | doola says it works with entrepreneurs from around the world and that you do not need to be a US citizen. Confirm your country is offered at checkout | Non-US residents can use Start, with no SSN or ITIN required for the EIN, but Firstbase publishes a restricted-country list in its terms — check it before you pay |
Sources for the cells above are the official pages listed at the bottom of this guide, checked November 14, 2026. The 3-year totals use the line items on our cost page, including official state fees. Wyoming's 2.4% online-payment fee is included on DIY rows there; provider rows show the $100 state fee each provider lists.
Do not stop at the first-year price
Headline prices are easy to misread. Atlas's $500 looks similar to Firstbase's $399 list fee until you add Firstbase's required $299-a-year agent and the state filing. doola(Paid link)'s $297 looks lower than both until you remember it is charged every year. Delaware's official $400 LLC tax, due June 1 of the following year, is why Atlas's 3-year total is close to Firstbase's Wyoming total even though Atlas bundles year-1 state fees.
In our table, year 1 is $500 for Atlas, $397 for doola Starter in Wyoming, and $798 for Firstbase Start plus Agent in Wyoming at list price. Years 2 and 3 together are what usually change the order. If Firstbase's $99 promotion still applies at checkout, year 1 would be $300 lower than our list-price figure; we cannot say how long that promotion lasts, because no end date was published.
Who each one fits
Stripe Atlas
Atlas fits a founder who wants a Delaware company — often a C-Corp with founder equity, 83(b) filing and SAFE tools, or an LLC if that structure is the better tax fit — and who is comfortable with Delaware's $400 official annual LLC tax (or the separate C-Corp franchise tax and annual report). It also fits someone who wants a direct path to apply for Stripe payments and Stripe Treasury after incorporation, knowing that approval is not guaranteed and that a Treasury account is not opened automatically. It is a weaker fit if you need a US mailbox in the same package, want to form in Wyoming, or need the provider to file Form 5472 at a published price.
doola
doola(Paid link) Starter fits a founder who wants an annual bundle: formation, an EIN without an SSN, a registered agent and a US business address, and who may later buy tax filing from the same provider. It currently ranks first in our formation ranking. The trade-off is the yearly $297 subscription (plus state fees), a discretionary refund that is only possible before the filing is sent to the state, and a slower EIN path if you have no SSN (typically 4–6 weeks, sometimes longer). Annual state-report filing and Form 5472 are not in Starter.
Firstbase
Firstbase fits a founder who wants Delaware or Wyoming, an EIN included, and a published Form 5472 add-on price ($899 a year for a non-US-owned single-member LLC). Budget the required $299-a-year Agent; that add-on, not the Start fee, dominates the 3-year total. Check Firstbase's restricted-country list before you pay, and treat the $99 Start price as a promotion until the pricing page says otherwise. Firstbase ranks second in our formation ranking, just behind doola.
Each of the three, in ranking order
We earn a commission if you sign up through some links in this section. It never changes scores or order.
The notes below are the same sourced facts, watch-outs and refund terms we publish on our other formation pages. Atlas appears last because it is not ranked.
doola#1 · score 74.6
doola pays us a commission when you buy after clicking our partner link. Use that link and code OUTSIDEFOUNDER10 at checkout. Covers: 10% off a new customer's first purchase of the Starter, Tax & Compliance, or Business in a Box plan. End date: No end date announced as of Last checked Nov 5, 2026. Check the final price at checkout.
Formation + EIN + compliance bundles aimed at non-residents. Often the easiest all-in-one option for non-residents, but pricier over 3 years. Get the inclusions in writing before you pay.
Cost basis: doola pricing: Starter $297/yr + state fees; annual state report filing is not in Starter (checked Oct 17, 2026).
Reviews: Trustpilot 4.4/5 (2,094 reviews), checked Nov 1, 2026.
- Year 2–3 renewal price shown on the formation pricing page: Yes (Starter $297/yr + state fees on the pricing page; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
- Registered-agent renewal price published: Yes (Registered agent is part of Starter at $297/yr; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
- Cancel self-serve in the online account (no ticket, email or call): No (Cancel by form or email; doola says there is no self-serve cancel option in the dashboard yet; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
- Automatic renewal disclosed in the terms or pricing: Yes ("Any recurring fees will automatically renew at the rates then in effect"; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
Watch-outs
- EIN timing: doola's help center no longer quotes a fixed range; it says timing depends on whether you have an SSN, on IRS manual review (common for non-US residents) and on the season. Some reviewers on Trustpilot report waits longer than expected. doola Help Center – How long does company formation take and when will I get my EIN?, last checked Nov 5, 2026.
- Some Trustpilot reviewers report being charged extra for filings they expected their plan to include. Ask which state and IRS filings each tier covers, in writing. Trustpilot (CA) – doola.com reviews, last checked Oct 17, 2026.
- Trustpilot's review summary notes that some customers reported delays with IRS paperwork and slow follow-up from support. Trustpilot – doola.com reviews, last checked Oct 17, 2026.
- Per doola's terms, recurring fees renew automatically until cancelled. doola – Terms of Service, last checked Oct 17, 2026.
Refunds: Refund may be possible if you cancel before your application is sent to the state; at doola's discretion. No refund once the state or a government agency is reviewing it. doola – Terms of Service, last checked Oct 17, 2026.
Firstbase#2 · score 72.4
Formation, registered agent and banking integrations. Smooth formation flow per many reviewers. Compare add-on prices and check the refund window.
Cost basis: Firstbase pricing: Start $399 list price, one-time. A $99 promotional price was shown on Oct 29, 2026 with no end date, so we use the list price; Agent $299 annually per state, required for incorporation (checked Oct 17, 2026).
Reviews: Trustpilot 4.3/5 (1,097 reviews), checked Nov 1, 2026.
- Year 2–3 renewal price shown on the formation pricing page: Yes (Agent $299 annually per state on the pricing page; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
- Registered-agent renewal price published: Yes (Agent $299 annually per state; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
- Cancel self-serve in the online account (no ticket, email or call): No (Terms: cancel by creating a support ticket at least ten business days before renewal; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
- Automatic renewal disclosed in the terms or pricing: Yes ("Customer's subscription will renew automatically at the then-current rates"; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
Watch-outs
- Firstbase's pricing page lists the registered agent ($299 a year per state) and a mailing address (Mailroom) as add-ons to Start, and says a registered agent is required. Budget for the agent every year. Firstbase – Pricing, last checked Oct 17, 2026.
- The money-back guarantee applies only within 7 calendar days of purchase and only before certain steps are done (see refund column). Firstbase – Terms (Money Back Guarantee), last checked Oct 17, 2026.
- Check the restricted-country list before you pay. As of Oct 29, 2026, Firstbase's Terms of Use say it can't accept applications from citizens of Albania, Bosnia, Burundi, Central African Republic, Croatia, Cyprus, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Iraq, Lebanon, Liberia, Libya, Macedonia, Montenegro, Nicaragua, Serbia, Slovenia, Somalia, South Sudan, Sudan, Venezuela, Yemen and Zimbabwe. Its refund terms separately list US-sanctioned countries and regions as places it can't form companies for. Firstbase – Terms (Money Back Guarantee), last checked Oct 17, 2026.
Refunds: 7-day money-back guarantee on Firstbase fees: full refund before the state filing; possibly 50% after registration but before the SS-4. No refunds after day 7 or once you confirm company details. State fees and Mailroom are non-refundable. Firstbase – Terms (Money Back Guarantee), last checked Oct 17, 2026.
Stripe AtlasNot ranked
Delaware C corp or LLC, $500 one-time incl. state fees and year-1 registered agent (per stripe.com/atlas).
Cost basis: Atlas $500 incl. government fees & yr-1 agent, then $100/yr, renews automatically (checked Oct 17, 2026).
- Year 2–3 renewal price shown on the formation pricing page: Yes ("$100 annually after your first year (renews automatically)" on the Atlas page; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
- Registered-agent renewal price published: Yes ($100 annually after year 1; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
- Cancel self-serve in the online account (no ticket, email or call): No (Terms: cancel the registered agent by giving 30 days' notice to atlas@stripe.com; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
- Automatic renewal disclosed in the terms or pricing: Yes (Atlas page and terms say the registered agent renews automatically; source, last checked Oct 18, 2026)
Watch-outs
- EIN timing: Stripe's Atlas docs say that if the founder doesn't have an SSN, Atlas gets the EIN in 5–35 business days after incorporation (1–3 business days with an SSN, US address and US phone). Stripe Docs – Sign up for Stripe Atlas, last checked Nov 14, 2026.
Official order or settlement on record: details and sources.
Northwest, doing it yourself, and related reading
If the 3-year total is your main constraint, also look at Northwest Registered Agent (Wyoming 3-year total $712 in our table, with a $200 add-on if you need an EIN without an SSN) and at the DIY rows on our cost page. You can file with the state yourself, hire a registered agent, and apply for a free EIN from the IRS; our EIN without SSN guide covers that IRS step. An LLC is only useful if you can open an account — run the roadmap wizard for your country before you pay anyone.
- Best LLC formation service for non-US founders (full ranking, including Northwest)
- doola alternatives and Firstbase alternatives
- LLC vs C-Corp for non-US founders (which entity type to pick before choosing a service)
- Wyoming vs Delaware vs New Mexico
- Form 5472 for a foreign-owned LLC and BOI reporting in 2026
- Stripe for non-US founders and US business bank account without an SSN
FAQ
Which is cheapest over three years: Stripe Atlas, doola or Firstbase?
In our 3-year cost table, doola Starter in Wyoming totals $1,114, Stripe Atlas (Delaware LLC) totals $1,500, and Firstbase Start plus Agent in Wyoming totals $1,519 at the $399 list price. Atlas looks cheaper in year 1 because the $500 fee includes Delaware's formation filing; Delaware's $400 official LLC tax is due from year 2 in our cash-timing table. Northwest Registered Agent in Wyoming is lower still, at $712, but it is a different package (EIN without an SSN is a $200 add-on). Figures are from our cost page; confirm live prices on each provider's site.
Does Stripe Atlas automatically get me a Stripe merchant account or a bank account?
No. Atlas can form the company and file for an EIN. After incorporation you can apply for Stripe payments and open a Stripe Treasury business account, including before the EIN arrives, but Atlas states it cannot guarantee approval for Stripe payments, and a Treasury account is not opened automatically. Other banks and payment providers may still require an EIN.
Can a non-US founder use all three?
Yes, with caveats. Atlas says founders from anywhere can form a Delaware company without being a US citizen or resident and without a US address or SSN. doola says it works with entrepreneurs around the world and obtains an EIN with or without an SSN. Firstbase says you do not need to be a US resident and that no SSN or ITIN is required for the EIN, but its terms list countries it cannot accept applications from — check that list before you pay.
Do any of these entry packages include Form 5472?
No. A foreign-owned single-member LLC typically still has to file Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120 each year. doola sells that as standalone Annual IRS Tax Filing ($1,500/yr) or inside Tax & Compliance ($1,999/yr). Firstbase lists Tax Filing for a non-US-owned single-member LLC at $899/yr. Atlas does not publish a price and points to partner tax services.
Does a US LLC formed with these services still have to file a FinCEN BOI report?
No. FinCEN's August 2026 final rule exempts companies created in the United States, including foreign-owned Wyoming or Delaware LLCs, from beneficial ownership information reports. Bank and payment-provider KYC is a separate requirement. Firstbase's Agent product still listed “beneficial ownership information filings” on its pricing page on November 14, 2026; we could not verify whether that is a FinCEN BOI filing or something else, or whether it costs extra. Decline a paid FinCEN BOI filing for a US-created LLC and read our BOI guide.
Does a commission change which provider comes first?
No. Partner status and commissions are not inputs to the score or the order. Only reviews, price transparency and refund terms are. The method is on our How we rank page.
Sources
- Stripe Atlas
- Stripe Docs – How to incorporate your company
- Stripe Docs – Atlas business taxes
- Stripe Atlas Terms of Service
- doola – Pricing
- doola Help – What is doola Starter plan?
- doola – How long does company formation take and when will I get my EIN?
- doola – Subscription and add-on service pricing
- doola – Does Tax and Compliance cover Form 5472?
- doola – Wyoming LLC (states doola says it can form in)
- doola – Terms of Service
- Firstbase – Pricing
- Firstbase – Start with Firstbase
- Firstbase – Terms
- Delaware Division of Corporations – LLC/LP/GP Franchise Tax Instructions
Rules change. Spotted something out of date? Email hello@outsidefounder.com.
Get a roadmap organized by your answers
6 questions → 6 milestones, 8–10 steps with costs, timelines and fixes.