OutsideFounder

LLC vs C-Corp for non-US founders (2026): taxes, filings and when to switch

By the OutsideFounder editorial team (Heroes Lab LLC) · Editorial policy · Last updated · 11 min read

Links on this page don't earn us a commission and go to providers' official sites. No provider gives us a free account, perk or other benefit.

General information, not legal, tax, or immigration advice. Disclaimer · How we make money

This is the choice most non-US founders face first, and formation services do not always explain it neutrally. This page sets out what each structure means for US tax, yearly filings, investors, banking and payments, then gives a decision table.

Short answer

As of : If you live outside the US, sell online, and do not plan to raise venture capital soon, a single-member LLC is usually the simpler start. By default it is a disregarded entity, so it pays no US corporate tax. If its income is not effectively connected with a US trade or business (ECI), you often owe no US federal income tax. It still files Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120 every year, and the penalty for missing that is $25,000. A C-Corp pays a flat 21% federal tax on its profit, and dividends paid to you are subject to 30% US withholding unless a tax treaty lowers the rate. In exchange, you get the structure US investors expect, stock options, and (for US-taxpaying holders) the QSBS exclusion. You can convert an LLC to a C-Corp later, but plan it with a CPA. This is general information, not tax advice.

Key facts

Verified against official sources on .

ItemValueSource
Default tax treatment of a single-member LLCDisregarded entity; can elect corporate treatment on Form 8832IRS – Instructions for Form 1120 (LLCs)
Foreign-owned single-member LLC filingForm 5472 attached to a pro forma Form 1120, by the 1120 due date (15th day of the 4th month after year-end; April 15 for calendar years)IRS – Instructions for Form 5472
Form 5472 penalty$25,000 per form; +$25,000 per 30-day period if not filed within 90 days after an IRS noticeIRS – Instructions for Form 5472
Federal corporate income tax rate (C-Corp)21% of taxable incomeIRS – Publication 542, Corporations
US withholding on dividends to foreign persons30%, unless a treaty or Code section provides a lower rate; reported on Form 1042-S by March 15IRS – NRA withholding; Instructions for Form 1042-S
Branch profits tax (foreign corporations with a US business)30% of effectively connected earnings not reinvested in the US business (treaties may reduce it)IRS – Instructions for Form 1120-F
QSBS exclusion (stock acquired after July 4, 2025)50% after 3 years, 75% after 4, 100% after 5; cap: greater of $15M or 10× basis per issuer; corporation's gross assets ≤ $75M at issuance26 U.S.C. § 1202 (Cornell LII)
Delaware corporation yearly cost$50 annual report + franchise tax: $175 minimum (Authorized Shares method) or $400 minimum (Assumed Par Value Capital method), due March 1Delaware Division of Corporations – Annual report and franchise tax
Delaware LLC yearly cost$400 annual tax, due June 1; no annual reportDelaware Division of Corporations – LLC tax instructions
Wyoming LLC or corporation$100 to form; annual report license tax $60 minimum (or $0.0002 per dollar of Wyoming assets, if greater)Wyoming Secretary of State – Fee schedule

This is general information, not tax or legal advice. The right structure depends on where you live, your home country's tax rules and any treaty with the US, where you and your team work, and your plans for investors. Use this page to prepare questions for a licensed CPA or enrolled agent, and a startup lawyer if you plan to raise.

The two structures in one paragraph each

Single-member LLC. By default, a US LLC with one owner is a disregarded entity for federal income tax: it does not pay federal income tax itself, and its income is treated as the owner's (IRS Form 1120 instructions). For a non-US owner, the main question is whether that income is effectively connected with a US trade or business. Even when no tax is due, the IRS treats a foreign-owned disregarded LLC as a corporation for one purpose: it must file Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120 every year it has reportable transactions with its owner (Form 5472 instructions).

C-Corp. A US corporation is a separate US taxpayer. It files Form 1120 every year and pays a flat 21% federal tax on its taxable income (IRS Publication 542), wherever its customers or founders are. Profits paid out to you as dividends are taxed again, by withholding. If at least 25% of it is foreign-owned, it also attaches Form 5472 to its Form 1120.

An S corporation is not an option: the IRS lists nonresident aliens among the shareholders an S corporation cannot have (IRS: S corporations).

Side by side

Single-member LLC (default)C-Corp
Federal entity-level taxNone; income is treated as the owner's21% of taxable income
Your US tax if income is not ECIOften no US federal income tax; certain US-source passive income can still face 30% withholdingThe company still pays 21%; dividends to you face 30% withholding or the treaty rate
Your US tax if income is ECIYou file a US nonresident return and pay graduated individual rates on the net ECISame 21% at company level; you are taxed only on what you take out
Yearly federal filingPro forma 1120 + Form 5472 (fax or mail only)Full Form 1120 + Form 5472 if 25%+ foreign-owned; Forms 1042/1042-S if it pays dividends
Missing Form 5472$25,000 penalty$25,000 penalty
Taking money outDistributions, which are not dividends (report them on Form 5472)Dividends (withholding), or pay for real services, sourced where you do the work
Venture investors, SAFEs, stock optionsAwkward; many US VCs do not invest in LLCsThe standard structure, usually in Delaware
QSBS (Section 1202)Not available (no stock)Available to qualifying non-corporate shareholders
Form W-9 or W-8 to payersThe owner usually gives Form W-8BEN (individual) or W-8BEN-E (foreign company)The company gives Form W-9
Typical stateWyoming or New Mexico (low fixed cost); Delaware also worksDelaware

Sources for each row are linked in the sections below and listed at the bottom of this page.

US tax on an LLC: the ECI and no-ECI cases

The IRS says that when a foreign person is engaged in a US trade or business, US-source income connected with that business is effectively connected income (ECI). Personal services performed in the US usually count, but the activity must be “considerable, continuous and regular”. ECI is taxed, after deductions, at the same graduated rates that apply to US citizens and residents (IRS: ECI). Because a single-member LLC is disregarded, its activity is treated as yours.

No ECI

A typical example is a founder who lives and works abroad, has no US office, employees or dependent agents, and sells software or digital services online. Often that income is not ECI, so no US federal income tax is due on it. The LLC still files Form 5472 with a pro forma 1120. Certain US-source passive income, such as US dividends or some royalties, is a separate category. It is generally subject to 30% withholding unless a treaty lowers it (IRS: NRA withholding). Your home country will usually tax the profit, because to it the LLC is often just you.

ECI

Your income is more likely to be ECI if you or your team work in the US, you keep a US office or warehouse, or you sell inventory with a US sale location. Then you file a US nonresident individual return and pay tax at graduated rates on the net ECI, and some states may tax it too. A tax treaty can change the outcome: under many treaties, US tax on business profits depends on whether you have a permanent establishment in the US.

When a foreign company owns the LLC

If the owner is a foreign corporation rather than you personally, ECI is taxed to that corporation on Form 1120-F, and the branch profits tax can also apply. That tax is 30% of effectively connected earnings that are not reinvested in the US business, and some treaties lower it (IRS Form 1120-F instructions). This is one of the main reasons groups with a foreign parent often use a US C-Corp subsidiary instead. Get advice if this is your setup.

Form 5472 and the pro forma 1120 (both structures)

A foreign-owned single-member LLC has no income tax return of its own. Instead, it must file a pro forma Form 1120 with Form 5472 attached, by the 1120 due date. That date is the 15th day of the 4th month after year-end, so April 15 for a calendar year, and Form 7004 extends it. The pro forma 1120 needs only the name, address and items B and E on page 1. It cannot be e-filed, so it is faxed or mailed to a dedicated IRS address (Form 5472 instructions). Reportable transactions include contributions to and distributions from the LLC, and amounts paid to form it. In practice, nearly every foreign-owned LLC files every year.

The penalty for not filing, or for filing a substantially incomplete form, is $25,000 per form. Another $25,000 applies for each 30-day period the failure continues more than 90 days after an IRS notice (IRS: international information reporting penalties). A C-Corp that is at least 25% foreign-owned also attaches Form 5472 to its full Form 1120. See our Form 5472 guide for the filing steps.

US tax on a C-Corp: 21%, then dividend withholding

A US C-Corp pays 21% federal tax on its taxable income (Publication 542), plus any state income tax where it does business. It must file Form 1120 every year, whether or not it has taxable income (Form 1120 instructions). ECI does not matter for the corporation itself, because it is a US taxpayer on all of its income.

When the company pays you a dividend, that dividend is US-source income to a foreign person. It is generally subject to 30% withholding, unless a tax treaty with your country of residence lowers the rate (NRA withholding; Publication 515; IRS tax treaty tables). The company withholds the tax, files Form 1042, and issues you a Form 1042-S by March 15 of the following year (Form 1042-S instructions). To claim a treaty rate, you usually give the company Form W-8BEN. A foreign company shareholder gives Form W-8BEN-E (Form W-8BEN-E instructions).

Simple arithmetic, federal only: on $100,000 of profit, the C-Corp pays $21,000 of tax. If it pays out the remaining $79,000 as a dividend, 30% withholding takes $23,700, so you receive $55,300. At a 15% treaty rate, withholding would be $11,850. If the company keeps the profit to grow, only the 21% applies for now. Your home country may tax the dividend again, possibly with a credit for the US tax. Ask your CPA.

Pay for real work is different from a dividend. The IRS sources compensation for personal services to where the services are performed (Publication 519). So reasonable pay for work you do outside the US is generally not US-source income to you, and it is usually deductible for the company. The amount and the paperwork have to hold up, so set this up with a CPA rather than improvising.

When a Delaware C-Corp is the right call

  • You plan to raise from US venture investors or accelerators. Priced rounds, SAFEs and standard investor documents assume a corporation, and Delaware is the common default. Investors generally do not want an LLC, because its profits and losses pass through to its owners.
  • You want to grant stock options to employees. Option plans are built for corporations.
  • QSBS matters to your cap table. Section 1202 lets non-corporate holders of qualified small business stock in a domestic C-Corp exclude part or all of their gain. For stock acquired after the July 4, 2025 enactment of P.L. 119-21, the exclusion is 50% after 3 years, 75% after 4 and 100% after 5. It is capped per issuer at the greater of $15 million or 10 times basis, and the company's gross assets must not exceed $75 million when the stock is issued (26 U.S.C. § 1202). This helps US-taxpaying co-founders, employees and investors most. A nonresident who spends fewer than 183 days a year in the US is generally not taxed by the US on capital gains that are not ECI anyway (Publication 519).
  • You will keep most profit in the company. A flat 21% with no tax until distribution can beat graduated individual rates on ECI.
  • A foreign parent company will own the US business. A C-Corp subsidiary can avoid the branch profits tax analysis described above.

Stripe Atlas, a common route for non-US founders, forms Delaware C-Corps and LLCs. Its homepage pitches incorporating “a startup that's ready to raise”, and its FAQ says C-Corps are commonly used by startups that plan to raise venture capital or issue stock to employees, while LLCs can fit businesses that want more flexible ownership and tax treatment (stripe.com/atlas). If you do not plan to raise, do not pick the C-Corp just because it is listed first. Our Stripe Atlas vs doola vs Firstbase comparison covers the formation services themselves.

Banking, Stripe and getting paid

  • Both structures can open accounts. US business banks, fintech accounts and Stripe accept LLCs and corporations. Approval depends mostly on your EIN, company documents, country of residence and business model, not on the entity type. See US business bank account without an SSN and Stripe for non-US founders.
  • Tax forms differ. A corporation organized under US state law is a US person and gives payers Form W-9. For a foreign-owned single-member LLC, the IRS says the disregarded entity generally does not submit a W-8 itself; its foreign owner gives Form W-8BEN (individual) or W-8BEN-E (entity) (Form W-8BEN-E instructions). Expect payment platforms to ask about this during onboarding.
  • Moving money to yourself. From an LLC, you take distributions. These are not dividends and carry no US withholding, but they are reportable transactions on Form 5472. From a C-Corp, money comes out as dividends with withholding, or as documented pay for services. Keep company and personal money separate in both cases.
  • EIN. Both structures need an EIN for a bank account and for Stripe. The IRS process is the same; see EIN without an SSN.

State choice: Wyoming, Delaware or New Mexico

The state changes fixed yearly costs and corporate-law familiarity. It does not change your federal tax.

WyomingDelawareNew Mexico
LLC formation$100$110$50
LLC yearlyAnnual report license tax, $60 minimum$400 annual tax, due June 1No LLC annual report
Corporation formation$100From $109 (varies with authorized stock)Rarely chosen for corporations; check the Secretary of State
Corporation yearlyAnnual report license tax, $60 minimum$50 annual report + franchise tax ($175 minimum under the Authorized Shares method, $400 minimum under the Assumed Par Value Capital method), due March 1—
FitsSolo LLCs; low-cost corporations without VC plansVenture-backed C-Corps; LLCs whose partners ask for itSolo LLCs that want no annual report

Sources: Wyoming fee schedule; Delaware fee schedule (revised August 1, 2026), Delaware corporate annual report and franchise tax, Delaware LLC tax; New Mexico Secretary of State. Registered agent fees come on top and are set by private providers.

Delaware franchise tax watch-out. Startups often authorize millions of shares. Under the Authorized Shares method, that can produce a large franchise tax bill. Delaware also offers the Assumed Par Value Capital method, which has a $400 minimum and often produces a much smaller bill for an early-stage company. The maximum under either method is $200,000 (Delaware Division of Corporations). Check both methods before you pay. More detail on LLC costs by state is in Wyoming vs Delaware vs New Mexico.

Converting an LLC to a C-Corp later

Starting as an LLC does not lock you in. There are two separate levers:

  • Tax election only (Form 8832). An LLC can elect to be taxed as a corporation without changing its legal form. The election can take effect no more than 75 days before it is filed and no more than 12 months after. After a change, the entity generally cannot change its classification again for 60 months. When a disregarded entity elects corporate status, the owner is treated as contributing all of the LLC's assets and liabilities to the corporation in exchange for its stock (IRS Form 8832 and instructions). That gives you the 21% tax treatment, but not the corporate legal form investors expect.
  • Statutory conversion (legal form). Delaware's corporation law allows another entity to convert into a Delaware corporation (Delaware Code Title 8, Subchapter IX). The state fee is $184, plus a certificate of incorporation filed at the same time, plus any tax a converting Delaware entity owes (Delaware fee schedule). Wyoming allows an LLC to convert to a profit corporation under W.S. 17-29-1009 by filing articles of incorporation with a conversion statement, for a $100 fee (Wyoming conversion information). A Wyoming LLC that wants to become a Delaware corporation usually needs more steps, so ask a lawyer.

Things to settle with a CPA and lawyer before converting: the tax treatment of the deemed contribution, the value of what goes into the corporation, the company's EIN, bank and Stripe account updates, and the final LLC-year Form 5472. Also note the QSBS clock. Stock received for property is treated as acquired on the exchange date, with a basis of at least the property's fair market value (§ 1202(i)), so the holding period starts at conversion. Converting a few months before a funding round is common. Converting during one is stressful.

Decision table

Your situationUsually points toWhy
Solo founder abroad, selling software or digital services online, no US team, no plan to raiseSingle-member LLC (Wyoming or New Mexico)No entity-level US tax; income often not ECI; lowest fixed cost. Form 5472 is still required
Planning to raise from US VCs or join a US accelerator in the next 12–18 monthsDelaware C-CorpThe investor-standard structure for SAFEs, priced rounds and option plans
Hiring and granting stock optionsDelaware C-CorpOption plans are built for corporations
US-taxpaying co-founders or early employeesC-CorpQSBS can matter a lot to them
Profits will be taken out every yearLLCAvoids 21% tax followed by dividend withholding
Profits will mostly be reinvested, and the business has US ECIC-Corp, or an LLC taxed as a corporationA flat 21% instead of graduated individual rates on ECI
A foreign company will own the US businessOften a C-Corp subsidiaryAvoids running the branch profits tax analysis on an LLC branch
Not sure yetLLC now, convert before fundraisingCheaper to run; conversion is a known path

Whatever you choose, there is no FinCEN BOI report for a company created in the US (BOI guide). Bank and payment-provider KYC still applies.

Questions to bring to your CPA

  • Is any of my income effectively connected with a US trade or business, and does a treaty with my country require a permanent establishment first?
  • How does my home country tax a disregarded US LLC, and how would it tax dividends from a US C-Corp? Is there a credit for US withholding?
  • What dividend withholding rate does the treaty give me, and what form do you need from me?
  • If I start as an LLC, when and how should I convert, and what does that do to my QSBS holding period and to Form 5472 for the final LLC year?
  • Which state income or franchise taxes apply where I actually do business?

Related reading: US LLC taxes for non-residents, US LLC for non-residents, best LLC formation service for non-US founders.

Next step: Decided on an LLC and want a service to form it? Compare formation services in our ranked list of LLC services for non-US founders.

FAQ

Is an LLC or a C-Corp better for a non-US founder?

Neither is better for everyone. A single-member LLC is usually simpler and cheaper for a solo founder who sells online, takes profits out, and has no US-based team. Its income is often outside US federal income tax when it is not effectively connected with a US trade or business. A Delaware C-Corp is the standard choice if you plan to raise from US investors, grant stock options, or keep profits in the company. It pays 21% federal tax, and dividends to you face 30% withholding unless a treaty lowers that rate. Confirm with a CPA who knows your home country's rules.

Does a foreign-owned single-member LLC pay US tax?

The LLC itself pays no federal income tax, because by default it is disregarded and its income is treated as yours. You owe US federal income tax only on income that is effectively connected with a US trade or business (taxed at graduated rates on a nonresident return), or on certain US-source passive income. Either way, the LLC must file Form 5472 with a pro forma Form 1120 each year it has reportable transactions with you, which includes forming and funding it. Your home country may tax the income too.

What is the penalty for not filing Form 5472?

$25,000 per form. If the failure continues more than 90 days after an IRS notice, another $25,000 applies for each 30-day period (or part of one). A substantially incomplete form counts as not filed. This applies to foreign-owned single-member LLCs and to 25% foreign-owned C-Corps.

How are dividends from a US C-Corp to a non-US shareholder taxed?

The company first pays 21% federal corporate tax on its profit. Dividends to a foreign shareholder are then generally subject to 30% US withholding, unless a tax treaty between the US and your country of residence lowers the rate. The company withholds the tax, files Form 1042 and issues Form 1042-S (due March 15 of the following year). It usually collects your Form W-8BEN to apply a treaty rate.

Can a nonresident own an S corporation?

No. The IRS lists nonresident aliens among the shareholders an S corporation cannot have. A non-US founder is choosing between an LLC (disregarded or elected to be taxed as a corporation) and a C-Corp.

Do I need a Delaware C-Corp to use Stripe or open a US bank account?

No. Stripe and US business banks and fintech accounts work with both LLCs and corporations. Approval depends mainly on your company's documents, your EIN, your country of residence and your business. A C-Corp is a US person and gives payers Form W-9. For a foreign-owned single-member LLC, payers usually ask the owner for Form W-8BEN, because the LLC is disregarded.

Does QSBS help a non-US founder?

Mostly indirectly. Section 1202 lets non-corporate taxpayers exclude gain on qualified small business stock in a domestic C-Corp. For stock acquired after July 4, 2025, the exclusion is 50% after 3 years, 75% after 4 and 100% after 5, capped at the greater of $15 million or 10 times basis per issuer. It matters to US-taxpaying co-founders, employees and investors. A nonresident who is in the US for fewer than 183 days a year generally has no US tax on capital gains that are not effectively connected income anyway.

Can I start as an LLC and convert to a C-Corp later?

Yes. Delaware and Wyoming both allow a statutory conversion of an LLC into a corporation. Delaware charges a $184 conversion fee plus a certificate of incorporation filed at the same time; Wyoming charges $100. Alternatively, an LLC can elect to be taxed as a corporation with Form 8832, without changing its legal form. Converting has tax effects and investor-paperwork effects, and for QSBS the stock's holding period starts at conversion. Plan it with a CPA and a startup lawyer before a funding round.

Sources

Rules change. Spotted something out of date? Email hello@outsidefounder.com.

Get a roadmap organized by your answers

6 questions → 6 milestones, 8–10 steps with costs, timelines and fixes.

Start free →