doola alternatives for non-US founders: Northwest, Firstbase and Stripe Atlas compared
By the OutsideFounder editorial team (Heroes Lab LLC) · Editorial policy · Last updated · 8 min read
We earn a commission if you sign up through some links on this page. It never changes scores or order.
General information, not legal, tax, or immigration advice. Disclaimer · How we make money
Short answer
As of : doola Starter is a yearly bundle: formation, EIN filing, a registered agent and a US address for $297/yr plus the state fee. In Wyoming that package totals $1,114 over 3 years in our cost table (prices checked Nov 5, 2026). People usually shop around because that 3-year total is higher than filing with Northwest or doing it yourself, because a refund is only possible before the application is sent to the state and only at doola's discretion, or because Form 5472 is not in Starter. Stay if you want that bundle in one place and are comfortable with the yearly fee and the cancel-by-form-or-email process.
This page is for founders who are already looking at doola Starter, or who already bought it, and want a clear stay-or-leave decision. It is not a general ranking of every formation service. For that ranking, the published method and the full side-by-side, use our best LLC formation service guide.
Starter is the plan we price: $297/yr plus the state fee, covering formation, EIN filing, a registered agent and a US address (checked Nov 5, 2026). Our doola walkthrough covers the steps and watch-outs in more detail. The question here is whether that yearly bundle is still the right fit, or whether a cheaper or more limited path is enough.
Why people leave, or skip, doola Starter
These are the gaps we can source from doola(Paid link)'s own pages, its terms, and our 3-year cost table. They are the reasons a founder who was about to buy Starter, or who is already on it, usually starts comparing.
- The 3-year total. Starter renews at $297/yr. In Wyoming, with the state fee and Wyoming's annual report, that package totals $1,114 over 3 years. Northwest's Wyoming package in the same table is $712; filing yourself in Wyoming is $375–$675. Cheaper paths usually mean you handle the EIN, the US address, or both yourself, or you pay for them as add-ons.
- The refund is narrow and discretionary. Refund may be possible if you cancel before your application is sent to the state; at doola's discretion. No refund once the state or a government agency is reviewing it. Once the state or a government agency is reviewing the filing, doola's terms say there is no refund.
- Form 5472 is not in Starter. Not in Starter ($297/yr). Included in Tax & Compliance ($1,999/yr). Standalone Annual IRS Tax Filing: $1,500/yr (covers Form 5472 and pro forma 1120 when they apply). A foreign-owned single-member LLC still has to file it every year; Starter does not take that off your plate.
- Cancellation is not self-serve. Recurring fees renew automatically until you cancel, per doola's terms. doola's help center says you cancel by form or email, and that there is no self-serve cancel option in the dashboard yet (checked Oct 17, 2026).
- EIN timing is not a fixed range. doola's help center says timing depends on whether you have an SSN, on IRS manual review (common for non-US residents) and on the season. Some Trustpilot reviewers report waits longer than they expected (checked 5 November 2026).
- Ask what each tier actually files. Some Trustpilot reviewers report being charged extra for filings they expected their plan to include. Get which state and IRS filings Starter covers for your case, in writing, before you pay.
Who should stay with doola
We earn a commission if you sign up through some links in this section. It never changes scores or order.
Starter is still a reasonable fit when you want one vendor to file the LLC, apply for the EIN, act as registered agent and provide a US mailing address, and you would rather pay a yearly bundle than assemble those pieces yourself. It also fits if you expect to buy doola's Tax & Compliance plan ($1,999/yr, which includes Form 5472) or the standalone Annual IRS Tax Filing ($1,500/yr) later, so keeping formation and tax filing with the same company matters to you.
It is a weaker fit if the 3-year cash difference versus Northwest or DIY is the main issue, if you need a documented refund right after the state has the filing, or if you want to cancel a renewal from a dashboard without a form or email. Get the inclusions in writing before you pay, including which state you will be formed in and whether annual report filing is or is not in Starter (it is not, in the pricing we checked).
What you keep or give up if you leave Starter
This is not our full ranking table. It only compares the bundle pieces Starter includes against the paths people actually switch to. 3-year totals come from our cost comparison (prices checked Nov 5, 2026). Wyoming rows include the state annual report; Stripe Atlas is a Delaware package and includes Delaware's LLC tax in years 2 and 3.
| Path | 3-year total in our table | Registered agent and US address vs Starter | Form 5472 + pro forma 1120 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stay on doola(Paid link) Starter (Wyoming) | $1,114doola (Starter) | Both included in the $297/yr plan. | Not in Starter; in Tax & Compliance ($1,999/yr) or standalone Annual IRS Tax Filing ($1,500/yr) |
| Switch to Northwest (Wyoming) | $712Northwest Registered Agent | Year-1 agent and a US address included; agent then $125/yr. An EIN without an SSN is a $200 add-on, which Starter already includes. | Not offered on its public pages |
| Switch to Firstbase Start + Agent (Wyoming) | $1,519Firstbase (Start + Agent) | Agent is a required add-on at $299/yr per state. A US mailing address is a separate Mailroom add-on (from $35/mo or $315/yr), which Starter includes. | Add-on (Tax Filing, $899/yr for a non-US-owned single-member LLC) |
| Switch to Stripe Atlas (Delaware LLC) | $1,500Stripe Atlas (LLC) | Year-1 agent included, then $100/yr. Atlas does not include a US mailing address. | Not included; Atlas points to partner tax services (no price published by Atlas) |
| File it yourself in Wyoming | $375–$675DIY (you file, hire an agent) | You hire a registered agent (we estimate $50–$150/yr) and arrange any US address yourself. The IRS charges $0 for an EIN if you fax Form SS-4. | You file, or you hire a tax preparer; this path does not come with a formation-service add-on. |
Leaving Starter for Firstbase or Atlas does not automatically lower the 3-year total in our table. The cash saving versus Starter shows up on the Northwest and DIY rows. Firstbase's 3-year Wyoming total is higher than Starter's because of the required Agent add-on; Atlas is a Delaware package, so years 2 and 3 include Delaware's $400 LLC tax.
Northwest, if the 3-year total is why you're leaving
Northwest is the usual cheaper service path away from Starter in our Wyoming numbers: $712 over 3 years, including the $200 EIN-without-SSN add-on. Formation is $39 plus the state fee, the first year of registered agent service is included, and the agent then renews at $125/yr (checked Oct 17, 2026). A US address is included; Starter also includes one, so you are not giving that up.
What you do give up: Starter already includes the EIN filing, and Northwest charges $200 for an owner without an SSN. Northwest also does not offer Form 5472 filing on its public LLC or pricing pages, so you would file it yourself or hire someone else. And Northwest's terms say registered-agent customers are automatically enrolled in its paid Compliance Services (annual report filing), invoiced at least 90 days before the filing is due; cancel that in your online account if you will file the report yourself. Refunds: purchases are non-refundable after 90 days, refunds or credits are at Northwest's sole discretion, and state filing fees are non-refundable.
Firstbase, if you wanted a one-time formation fee instead of $297/yr
Firstbase Start is $399 list price, one-time, for formation and EIN filing. That sounds like a way off Starter's yearly $297, but a registered agent is not in Start. Firstbase's pricing page lists Agent at $299 a year per state and says a registered agent is required, so our cost table prices Start + Agent. In Wyoming that package totals $1,519 over 3 years, which is more than Starter, not less. A US mailing address is a Mailroom add-on (from $35/mo or $315/yr); Starter includes an address, so you would be buying that separately.
Firstbase can still be the right switch if you prefer its 7-day money-back terms (full refund of Firstbase fees before the state filing, with tighter rules after that) to doola(Paid link)'s discretionary, pre-filing-only refund, or if you want Firstbase's Tax Filing add-on for a non-US-owned single-member LLC at $899/yr rather than doola's $1,500/$1,999 tax options. Check Firstbase's restricted-country list in its terms before you pay; our Firstbase alternatives page walks through that list and the refund window in detail. A $99 promotional Start price was shown on 29 October 2026 with no end date, so our table uses the $399 list price.
Stripe Atlas, if you actually want a Delaware LLC
Atlas forms in Delaware, not Wyoming. The $500 setup price includes state fees, the first year of registered agent service and EIN filing; the agent then renews at $100/yr. In our table the 3-year Delaware total is $1,500, which includes Delaware's $400 LLC tax in years 2 and 3. Atlas does not include a US mailing address, so you would be giving up an inclusion Starter has. If the founder has no SSN, Stripe's Atlas docs say the EIN arrives in 5–35 business days after incorporation. Atlas points to partner tax services for Form 5472 and does not publish a price. Choose Atlas because you want Delaware (or the Atlas/Stripe path), not because it is a drop-in cheaper Starter substitute.
Filing the LLC yourself, if you only needed the bundle for convenience
You can file with the Wyoming Secretary of State (or another state), hire a registered agent, and fax Form SS-4 to the IRS yourself. The IRS charges $0 for an EIN. Our cost page prices this DIY path in Wyoming at $375–$675 over 3 years, with the registered-agent line as our $50–$150/yr estimate. You arrange any US mailing address yourself, and you are responsible for the annual report and for Form 5472. The EIN without SSN guide covers the IRS step, and the cost page shows the same DIY path in Delaware if that is the state you want.
If you already paid doola: refund, cancel and switching
If the application has not been sent to the state, a refund may still be possible, at doola(Paid link)'s discretion. If the state or a government agency is already reviewing it, doola's terms say there is no refund. Cancelling the subscription is a separate step from the refund: use the form or email process in doola's help center, and do it before a renewal if you do not want the next $297 charge. Recurring fees renew automatically until you cancel.
If the LLC already exists, cancelling doola does not dissolve it. Replace the registered agent and, if you used doola's US address, replace that address, and do both before the current terms end. Confirm the dates in your account and with the state. Form 5472, if it applies, still has to be filed each year whether or not you buy doola's tax add-on.
FAQ
Why do founders already looking at doola Starter shop around?
The usual triggers are the 3-year cash total ($1,114 for Starter in Wyoming in our table), the refund rule (Refund may be possible if you cancel before your application is sent to the state; at doola's discretion. No refund once the state or a government agency is reviewing it.), and Form 5472 not being in Starter (Not in Starter ($297/yr). Included in Tax & Compliance ($1,999/yr). Standalone Annual IRS Tax Filing: $1,500/yr (covers Form 5472 and pro forma 1120 when they apply).)
Can I get a refund after I start a doola application?
Refund may be possible if you cancel before your application is sent to the state; at doola's discretion. No refund once the state or a government agency is reviewing it.
How do I cancel a doola subscription?
doola's help center says you cancel by form or email, and that there is no self-serve cancel option in the dashboard yet. Recurring fees renew automatically at the rates then in effect until you cancel, per doola's terms.
Is Form 5472 included in doola Starter?
Not in Starter ($297/yr). Included in Tax & Compliance ($1,999/yr). Standalone Annual IRS Tax Filing: $1,500/yr (covers Form 5472 and pro forma 1120 when they apply).
If my LLC is already formed with doola, what do I have to replace if I leave?
Cancelling doola does not undo a filing the state has already accepted. You will need a new registered agent before the current term ends, and a new US mailing address if you have been using doola's. Confirm both dates in your doola account and with the state before you cancel.
Who should stay on doola Starter?
Founders who want EIN filing, a registered agent and a US address in one yearly plan, who are fine paying Starter every year, and who may later buy doola's Tax & Compliance plan or standalone Annual IRS Tax Filing for Form 5472. Get the inclusions for your state in writing before you pay.
Sources
- doola – Pricing
- doola – Terms of Service
- doola Help Center – How to cancel your subscription
- doola Help Center – How long does company formation take and when will I get my EIN?
- Firstbase – Pricing
- Firstbase – Terms
- Northwest – The Northwest LLC
- Northwest – Terms
- Northwest – EIN / Tax ID
- Stripe Atlas
- Stripe Docs – Sign up for Stripe Atlas
Rules change. Spotted something out of date? Email hello@outsidefounder.com.
Get a roadmap organized by your answers
6 questions → 6 milestones, 8–10 steps with costs, timelines and fixes.